In the perfectly normal town of Louisville, KY, there is a perfectly normal man living the perfect life. Gil Bellows stars as David Dailey - a man who has it all: A great career, a community that adores him, and an enduring marriage. But beneath the surface, David's idyllic world is crumbling. He's haunted by a series of mysterious notes that warn of an imminent fall from grace. His sultry wife Susan (Kim Raver) is hell-bent on expanding the horizons of their sex life - with or without him. His longtime assistant Whit (Jamie Harrold) is gunning for his job. And he finds himself increasingly attracted to Melody Carpenter (Jennifer Westfeldt), a curious stranger he instinctively trusts because she doesn't know him well enough to betray him. Complicating matters, Melody's jilted boyfriend Sean (Christian Kane), a charming and talented trust fund baby, regards David and Melody's fledgling friendship with contempt. As his jealousy seethes deeper, he concocts a devious plan to win her back,